This scene makes me feel so sick. The music and the voice acting combined with the knowledge that Namatame isn't the killer makes the perfect dark atmosphere.

Best part is Naoto, Kanji, and Yosuke of all people telling him to do it.

All this time, Yu being near emotionless, was played for laughs.

The Sister Complex Kingpin of Steel, everyone.

It's moments like this that makes the anime so good. It not only retells the game but adds depth to it.

Persona 5: Breaks laws many times to save lives with tricks.

This what happens when you piss off yu man dude gets scary

Knowing that Natarame had genuinely good intentions this is a horrid scene, but it brings out a more understandable side to Yu though he was very rash.

This is one of the most powerful scenes in Persona history, as it perfectly reflects the mental state of the player at this point. Namatame's shadow just mocked Nanako's death and you have the perfect opportunity to send him to where he should belong. And yet, there feels like something else. Something telling you this isn't the right thing to do. I was just completely silent when I watched this scene.

Holy shit. His fucking eyes at the end

Holy crap the slight red colour reflecting Yu's eyes

If you think about it, Yu’s shadow is what he faces here. “Facing yourself” isn’t always literal through the Metaverse, in this case Yu is tempted to blame Namatame and satiate his hatred.

Yu: what about my little sister? Did you give her a chance, did you?!

Good thing for Teddie didn't witness Yu's other side, could chill his spine than Mabufudyne.

Well once you find out the truth to why he really was doing it, you feel horrible. He really thought he was helping people

I feel as thought the majority of the people in the comments don't realize that Namatames not the real killer.

That bitch went Death Note for a second there! XD