Great review. I completely agree about the ‘rules toolbox’ approach. P&S and Black Powder are very easy to tweak to get things to work how you prefer.

I appreciate it's been a while since this review. I've used the free to download rule 'Victory without Quarter' for the British Civil Wars and enjoyed it. Card based and very simple. I'm looking to use them for 17th century Eastern armies too.

Thanks for the nice review! The command order system of P&S is really fun and reflect the improtance of a qualified leader

Nice review. My friends and I have played several 15mm 30 Years War games using these rules. I highly recommend the Last Argument of Kings, which you reviewed, as well as the ECW supplement, To Kill a King. I'd edited and laid out a player's aid sheet, that helps with running the game.

Are the rules fluid for those who want to play with smaller scales like 6 or 10mm?

Really confused about what is a unit. For example a regiment of two musket blocks with a pike block in the middle is that one unit or three?

Very helpful, thank you.

Nice review! Subbed.

I am so tired of Rick's long ass rules that don't add anything to the game apart from constant referring to the rulebook